Your revised manuscript should be submitted using the link provided in the decision email, and not as a new manuscript. a cover letter that provides any additional information requested by the editors.a response to each of the reviewers, replying to each of the points raised.a revised version of the manuscript that addresses the issues raised by the editor and peer reviewers. If you are invited to revise and resubmit your manuscript, you should follow the instructions provided by the editor in their decision email. Decline publication, typically on grounds of either there being insufficient support for the conclusions or a reassessment of the level of interest or advance in light of the reviewers' comments.Invite the authors to revise and resubmit their manuscript to address specific concerns.When all the reviewer reports are received, the editors decide to either: Reviewers are not identified to the authors, except at the request of the reviewer.įind out more about peer review. Authors may suggest reviewers these suggestions are often helpful, although they are not always followed. Reviewer selection is critical to the review process, and we work hard to ensure that the different technical and conceptual aspects of the work are covered. If the editor decides to send the manuscript to peer reviewers, they will contact researchers with relevant expertise. However, on occasion editors might consult with expert researchers when deciding whether to review a paper. Like other journals in the Nature family, Nature Methods has no external editorial board involved in editorial decision-making. Editors decide whether to send a manuscript for peer review based on the degree to which it advances our understanding of the field, the soundness of conclusions, the extent to which the evidence presented - including appropriate data and analyses - supports these conclusions, and the wide relevance of these conclusions to the journal’s readership. 2 – 3 First editorial decisionĪfter initial checks are complete, the manuscript is assigned to an editor, who reads the paper, consults with the editorial team, and decides whether it should be sent for peer review. Please see our guidelines for initial submission to make sure that you provide us with all necessary information at this stage. The journal’s editorial assistant will check that the manuscript and associated materials are complete. If the decision is positive, the author will usually be asked to revise the manuscript and resubmit. If the decision is negative, the author can choose to transfer the manuscript – including the reviewer comments to another journal.The editor contacts the author with the decision.The editor and the editorial team discuss the reviewer reports, and decide whether the manuscript or a revised version of it could be published in the journal.Reviewers read the manuscript and submit their reports. The editor contacts potential reviewers to ask them to review the manuscript.The editor and the editorial team decide whether or not to send the manuscript out to review the corresponding author is contacted with the decision.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |